Look, I’ve got an excuse. I was lazy.
In any event, what could have brought me out of my foxhole to blather away to precisely nobody? The Jays recent run? Of course not. Why, it’s our dear friend Richard Griffin!
From today’s mailbag:
Q-First I wanted to say thanks for all your answers and insight into the Jays, I look forward to your mailbag every Wednesday. My question is, If you were named Jays G.M what moves would you make, what free agents would you go for, or what would be your game plan for this powerless lineup of underachievers that Mr. Ricciardi has assembled? A loyal fan and reader.
Jonathan Sanchez, Toronto
Jonathan Sanchez is the new Ron Mexico. Anyway, this softball is right Griff’s wheelhouse. Let’s listen in:
As I always like to point out, GM Ed Wade of the Astros and GM Ned Coletti of the Dodgers were both former public relations guys in baseball – Wade with the Phillies, Pirates and Astros, Coletti with the Cubs – which makes me just as qualified as 6.7-percent of all major league GMs.
He really does mention this a lot. Part of me thinks Richard truly does believe himself to be fit to be a GM. As an aside, as a government worker during my summers in University, I am just as qualified to be leader of a sovereign nation as 100% of all heads of state.
One of my first moves would be to find every former major-league player living in Canada and put them on the Jays payroll as consultants, scouts and ambassadors. Then, I would increase funding to Greg Hamilton’s Baseball Canada program and take a more hands-on approach to our team in the World Baseball Classic.
Sure, why not. Neat idea. But how many former major-leaguers are currently living in Canada? Five or six?
I would sign free agent Carlos Delgado as a DH for one year until Travis Snider is ready and have him influence immature Puerto Rican star Alex Rios into maximizing his skills and focusing every day.
Not the worst idea. Delgado looked done about two months ago but has rebounded nicely. He may get more than a one year deal elsewhere but it’d be worth a shot.
I would sign Orlando Hudson and move Aaron Hill over to shortstop.
I sense a pattern. Shawn Green’s available too, you know.
I would trade for a young ready-for-prime time No. 2 or 3 starter and not be afraid to give up some premium prospects.
Me? I’d trade for Albert Pujols and David Wright. That’d shore up the infield nicely. Vagaries like the one above are essentially useless. What ready-for-prime time starter would you target? And which premium prospects would you deal? Surely not Snider as he’s in your 2010 plan as noted above. Brett Cecil? But he’s a nearly-ready-for-prime-time No. 2 or 3 starter. He’s what you’re trying to acquire!
I would hire an experienced senior advisor and some veteran scouts and actually listen to their advice.
Me too!
I would stay in Toronto all winter.
Not me. I’d winter on Pluto and conduct all transactions through Morse Code. Seriously, of all the things to rag on J.P. for, living in the US is about as far down the list as you can get. I don’t care if he lives in Fallujah if he can put a winning team on the field. Neither should you.
Ok, that was just an amuse bouche. Richard really turns up the crazy on the next question:
Q-I’ve previously asked you about evaluating the performance of pitchers using wins and losses and how that can be misleading, I now have a question for you about offensive statistics. I’ve noticed that more and more baseball experts have been leaning towards on-base percentage over batting average because walks are becoming more valuable and along with on-base percentage, Slugging percentage to create the all important OPS. My question for you is, do you think batting average will one day soon become obsolete?
Eric Sillius, Oakville
Get your pitchforks ready!
On-base percentage gained importance because certain teams on a budget were looking at players they could afford and weren’t highly scouted, that weren’t talented enough as hitters to post high batting averages but could swat the occasional longball.
OBP has always been important. It tells you how often a guy doesn’t get out. OBP gained prominence when Michael Lewis wrote a book about Billy Beane exploiting inefficiencies in the baseball marketplace. Then it became infamous when older baseball writers and ESPN analysts misinterpreted the book as an attack on the mystique of the game by computers.
You use the term loosely when you cite “baseball experts”.
And we’re at rock bottom. Come on, Richard. Is Billy Beane not a “baseball expert”? What about Bill James? Or absolutely anyone who attaches significance to a broader statistic than batting average? This is absurd.
Considering on-base percentage more important than batting average is not baseball. Jack Cust has a better on-base percentage than Ichiro Suzuki, but who’s the better player?
This doesn’t even make sense. No, it’s not baseball. It’s an opinion. And you’re insane.
Ryan Theriot has a higher batting average than Alex Rodriguez, but who’s the better player?
Vincente Padilla has more wins than Johan Santana, but who’s the better pitcher?
Mike Jacobs has more homeruns than Vlad Guerrero, but who’s the better player?
Michael Phelps has more world records than me, but who’s better at Sudoku? (It’s me, I’m fucking amazing at them).
I honestly don’t even know what else to say to that. It’s just a shame that people will read this and accept Griffin’s logic.
Anyway, see ya in a month or something.